| Year-School | Player |
| 1998-Michigan State* | |
| 1998-Northwestern | |
| 1998-Purdue | |
| 1998-Illinois | |
| 1998-Michigan | |
| 1999-Michigan State* | |
| 1999-Ohio State* | |
| 1999-Minnesota | |
| 1999-Northwestern | |
| 1999-Michigan State | |
| 2000-Michigan State* | |
| 2000-Indiana* | |
| 2000-Ohio State | |
| 2000-Ohio State | |
| 2000-Michigan State | |
| 2000-Penn State | |
| 2001-Illinois* | |
| 2001-Indiana | |
| 2001-Ohio State | |
| 2001-Penn State | |
| 2001-Michigan State | |
| 2001-Michigan State | |
| 2002-Indiana* | |
| 2002-Illinois | |
| | Year-School | Player |
| 2002-Wisconsin | |
| 2002-Michigan State | |
| 2002-Ohio State | |
| 2003-Illinois* | |
| 2003-Minnesota | |
| 2003-Purdue | |
| 2003-Michigan | |
| 2003-Wisconsin | |
| 2003-Indiana | |
| 2004-Wisconsin* | |
| 2004-Northwestern | |
| 2004-Illinois | |
| 2004-Michigan State | |
| 2004-Minnesota | |
| 2005-Illinois* | |
| 2005-Illinois | |
| 2005-Illinois | |
| 2005-Minnesota | |
| 2005-Wisconsin | |
| 2005-Indiana | |
| 2006-Ohio State* | |
| 2006-Illinois | |
| 2006-Iowa | |
| 2006-Wisconsin | |
| | Year-School | Player |
| 2006-Illinois | |
| 2006-Michigan | |
| 2007-Wisconsin* | |
| 2007-Ohio State | |
| 2007-Michigan State | |
| 2007-Iowa | |
| 2007-Purdue | |
| 2007-Ohio State | |
| 2008-Indiana* | |
| 2008-Indiana | |
| 2008-Purdue | |
| 2008-Wisconsin | |
| 2008-Michigan State | |
| 2008-Ohio State | |
| 2009-Michigan State* | |
| 2009-Ohio State | |
| 2009-Michigan | |
| 2009-Purdue | |
| 2009-Penn State | |
| 2010-Ohio State* | |
| 2010-Purdue | |
| 2010-Purdue | |
| 2010-Michigan State | |
| 2010-Illinois | |
|