| Movie Title(s) | Actress |
| The Blue Lagoon | |
| Tarzan, the Ape Man * | |
| Mommie Dearest * | |
| Butterfly | |
| The Lonely Lady | |
| Bolero | |
| Night Patrol / Savage Island / Savage Streets | |
| Shanghai Surprise | |
| Who's That Girl? | |
| Arthur 2: On the Rocks / Rent-A-Cop | |
| The Return of Swamp Thing | |
| Ghosts Can't Do It | |
| A Kiss Before Dying (as the twin who survives) | |
| Shining Through / A Stranger Among Us | |
| Body of Evidence | |
| Intersection / The Specialist | |
| Showgirls | |
| | Movie Title(s) | Actress |
| The Juror / Striptease | |
| G.I. Jane | |
| Spice World | |
| The Blair Witch Project | |
| The Next Best Thing | |
| Glitter | |
| Swept Away* | |
| Crossroads* | |
| Gigli | |
| Catwoman | |
| Dirty Love | |
| Basic Instinct 2 | |
| I Know Who Killed Me* (as Aubrey Fleming) | |
| I Know Who Killed Me* (as Dakota Moss) | |
| The Hottie and the Nottie | |
| All About Steve | |
| Only two 'winners' of the award have actually showed up and accepted their awards in person: (last names only) | |
|