| World Series Team | Pitcher | 2011 Team |
| NYY (r) | |
| COL (r) | |
| BOS (r) | |
| TB (r) | |
| ARI | |
| FLA/BOS | |
| PHI | |
| NYY (r) | |
| CWS | |
| SF | |
| NYY | |
| SF | |
| STL | |
| SF (r) | |
| NYY (r) | |
| NYY (r) | |
| NYY (r) | |
| CHW/NYY (r)* | |
| COL | |
| PHI (r) | |
| TEX (r) | |
| COL | |
| COL (r) | |
| CHW | |
| CHW | |
| TB | |
| PHI | |
| PHI (r) | |
| STL (r) | |
| COL (r) | |
| | World Series Team | Pitcher | 2011 Team |
| FLA/SF | |
| TEX (r) | |
| TB (r) | |
| NYY (r) | |
| TEX | |
| STL (r) | |
| TB (r) | |
| CHW (r) | |
| COL | |
| TEX (r) | |
| LAA | |
| PHI/TEX | |
| BOS | |
| TEX | |
| HOU/PHI (r) | |
| SF | |
| BOS/SF (r) | |
| BOS | |
| TEX (r) | |
| PHI (r) | |
| STL | |
| CHW/NYY (r) | |
| BOS | |
| TB (r) | |
| COL (r) | |
| SF (r) | |
| PHI | |
| TEX (r) | |
| TEX (r) | |
| BOS (r) | |
| | World Series Team | Pitcher | 2011 Team |
| TEX (r) | |
| LAA | |
| HOU | |
| BOS (r) | |
| FLA | |
| FLA | |
| TB (r) | |
| HOU (r) | |
| SF (r) | |
| NYY (r) | |
| NYY (r) | |
| DET (r) | |
| LAA (r) | |
| HOU (r) | |
| PHI (r) | |
| SF (r) | |
| NYY | |
| SF | |
| TB | |
| TB | |
| DET | |
| STL (r) | |
| BOS | |
| HOU/TB (r) | |
| FLA (r) | |
| SF (r) | |
| TEX | |
| DET (r) | |
|