| Hint | President | Explaination |
| His wife never saw the White House | |
| His top General later ran against him | |
| Star collegiate athlete | |
| Approved assassination attempts against a former Baltimore Orioles Prospect | |
| His brother had a beer named after him | |
| Won presidency by one electoral vote after the Florida elections were disputed | |
| Friends with John Arbuckle | |
| Has a poem about him | |
| First president to throw out the ceremonial 1st pitch at a baseball game | |
| Started a highly controversial war | |
| Often rode his horse side saddle into battle | |
| Born William Jefferson Blythe | |
| Had many cities named after him | |
| Carried a pair of pistols while presiding over the Senate while he was Vice President | |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |