| Hint | Player |
|---|
| Heisman-winning running back, #1 pick in NFL Draft, and All-Star Royals outfielder | |
| Hall of Fame starting pitcher (mostly for the Cubs and Rangers) who was also a Harlem Globetrotter | |
| Track star stripped of five medals from the 2000 Olympics who later played in the WNBA | |
| All-time great Bulls shooting guard; played minor league baseball between NBA stints | |
| Controversial champion amateur wrestler, WWE wrestler, and Ultimate Fighting heavyweight | |
| Six-time All-Star center fielder who went to the Final Four as an Arizona point guard in 1988 | |
| Hall of Famer who broke baseball's color line in 1947; track star and football All-American at UCLA | |
| Nine-time Pro Bowl cornerback and MLB outfielder nicknamed 'Prime Time' | |
| Native American Pro Football Hall of Famer; 1912 Olympics decathlon and pentathlon champion | |
| 1982 Heisman winner, Pro Bowl running back for the Cowboys, and 1992 Olympic bobsledder | |
| Heisman-winning quarterback who played point guard for the Knicks and was drafted by the Brewers | |
| X Games champion in snowboarding and skateboarding called 'The Flying Tomato' | |
| Won five Olympic swimming golds and a water polo bronze, then starred in 12 'Tarzan' films (1932-'48) | |
| Hall of Fame outfielder also drafted by the Hawks (NBA), Utah Stars (ABA), and Vikings (NFL) | |
| Olympic gold medal-winning track star who won ten LPGA golf majors and was a basketball All-American | |
NBA Players with Multiple MVPs
MLB Multiple MVP Winners
NHL Multiple MVP Winners
