| Year and Team | Player | OBP, HR |
| 2011 Angels | |
| 2004 Marlins | |
| 2003 Orioles | |
| 2010 Blue Jays | |
| 2004 Expos | |
| 2001 Blue Jays / Orioles | |
| 2006 Giants | |
| 2007 White Sox | |
| 2009 Giants | |
| 2010 Blue Jays | |
| 2004 White Sox | |
| 2011 Phillies | |
| 2011 Cubs | |
| 2007 Giants | |
| 2003 Dodgers | |
| 2010 Astros | |
| | Year and Team | Player | OBP, HR |
| 2007 Padres | |
| 2011 Angels | |
| 2006 Braves | |
| 2010 Blue Jays / Braves | |
| 2010 Cubs | |
| 2009 Rockies | |
| 2005 Giants | |
| 2003 Cubs | |
| 2011 Blue Jays | |
| 2007 Diamondbacks | |
| 2009 Phillies | |
| 2008 Marlins | |
| 2004 White Sox | |
| 2003 Mets / Dodgers | |
| 2008 Padres | |
|