| Team | Player | Year |
| Arsenal | |
| Aston Villa | |
| Aston Villa | |
| Arsenal | |
| Manchester United | |
| Manchester United | |
| Manchester United | |
| Chelsea/Charlton | |
| Newcastle United | |
| Newcastle United | |
| Liverpool | |
| Leeds United | |
| Arsenal | |
| Liverpool | |
| Manchester United | |
| Liverpool | |
| Liverpool | |
| Newcastle United | |
| Manchester United | |
| | Team | Player | Year |
| Manchester United | |
| Manchester United | |
| Southampton | |
| Arsenal | |
| Newcastle United | |
| Arsenal | |
| West Ham United | |
| Manchester United | |
| Luton Town | |
| Liverpool | |
| Southampton | |
| Aston Villa | |
| Tottenham Hotspur | |
| West Bromwich Albion | |
| Nottingham Forest | |
| Aston Villa | |
| Manchester City | |
| West Ham United | |
| Ipswich Town | |
|