| Hint | Answer |
| What does Dean scream at in 'Yellow Fever'? | |
| What is the name of another psychic like Sam? | |
| What can Max do? | |
| In 'Heart', who is Maddison's first known victim? | |
| What is Castiel's vessel's name? | |
| What is Castiel's vessel's daughter's name? | |
| Which demon possesses Sam? | |
| In which year did Samuel Colt make his gun? | |
| What is the significane of several fisherman going blind? | |
| Who is the second horseman to appear? | |
| In which episode is a cupid? | |
| What is the language of the Angels? | |
| Why did 'Yellow Eyes' kill Mary? | |
| How do you kill a vampire? | |
| How does Dean describe his Christmas presents? | |