| 1st Three Coaches | Team |
| John McKay, Leeman Bennett, Ray Perkins | |
| Ted Marchibroda, Brian Billick, John Harbaugh | |
| Damon Wetzel, Hugo Bezdek, Art Lewis | |
| Lud Wray, Bert Bell, Greasy Neale | |
| Forrest Douds, Luby DiMelio, Joe Bach | |
| Tom Landry, Jimmy Johnson, Barry Switzer | |
| Paddy Driscoll, Arnie Horween, Norman Barry | |
| Bob Folwell, Joe Alexander, Earl Potteiger | |
| Norb Hecker, Norm Van Brocklin, Marion Campbell | |
| Lud Wray, William Dietz, Eddie Casey | |
| Keith Molesworth, Weeb Ewbank, Don Shula | |
| Buck Shaw, Red Strader, Frankie Albert | |
| Dom Capers, George Seifert, John Fox | |
| Paul Brown, Bill Johnson, Homer Rice | |
| Lou Rymkus, Pop Ivy, Sammy Baugh | |
| Eddie Erdelatz, Marty Feldman, Red Conkright | |
| | 1st Three Coaches | Team |
| Tom Coughlin, Jack Del Rio | |
| George Wilson, Don Shula, Jimmy Johnson | |
| Sid Gillman, Charlie Waller, Harland Svare | |
| Norm Van Brocklin, Bud Grant, Les Steckel | |
| Lou Saban, Mike Holovak, Clive Rush | |
| Hal Griffin, George 'Potsy' Clark, Earl 'Dutch' Clark | |
| Dom Capers, Gary Kubiak | |
| Sammy Baugh, Bulldog Turner, Weeb Ewbank | |
| Tom Fears, J.D. Roberts, John North | |
| Frank Filchock, Jack Faulkner, Mac Speedie | |
| Hank Stram, Paul Wiggin, Tom Bettis | |
| Curly Lambeau, Gene Ronzani, Hugh Devore | |
| Paul Brown, Blanton Collier, Nick Skorich | |
| Jack Patera, Mike McCormack, Chuck Knox | |
| Buster Ramsey, Lou Saban, Joe Collier | |
| George Halas, Ralph Jones, Hunk Anderson | |
|