| Actor | Character | Hint (Season(s)) |
| #1 Denis Leary | |
| #2 John Scurti | |
| #3 Daniel Sunjata | |
| #4 Steven Pasquale | |
| #5 Mike Lombardi | |
| #6 Jack McGee | |
| #7 James McCaffrey | |
| #8 Larenz Tate | |
| #9 Michael Zegen | |
| #10 Adam Ferrara | |
| #11 Jerry Adler | |
| #12 Diane Farr | |
| | Actor | Character | Hint (Season(s)) |
| #13 Andrea Roth | |
| #14 Callie Thorne | |
| #15 Natalie Distler | |
| #16 Olivia Crocicchia | |
| #17 Trevor Heins/David Call | |
| #18 Robert John Burke | |
| #19 Lenny Clarke | |
| #20 Tatum O'Neal | |
| #21 Dean Winters | |
| #22 Terry Serpico | |
| #23 Charles Durning | |
| #24 (no credit listed) | |
| Bernardo De Paula | |
| Jessica Leccia | |
| Lee Tergesen | |
| Ed Sullivan | |
| Michael Mulheren | |
| Anthony Perullo | |
| Michael J. Fox | |
| Gina Gershon | |
| Maura Tierney | |
| Karina Lombard | |
| Milena Govich | |
| Susan Misner | |
| Cailin Stollar | |
| Susan Sarandon | |
| Sherri Saum | |
| Cornell Womack | |
| Tawny Cypress | |
| Patti D'Arbanville | |
| Cam Neely | |
| Phil Esposito | |
| Nice try--but that'd be way too easy! | |
|