| Hint | Player | Journey |
| 'The Curse' | |
| Center fielder for 2004 WS Red Sox | |
| HoF third baseman | |
| 3rd lowest ERA+ (106) for a HoF pitcher | |
| Pitched three shutouts in 1921 WS | |
| Known for his slider and 238 saves | |
| Struggling Red Sox outfielder traded while in AAA | |
| Though nicknamed 'bullet,' he became known for his forkball | |
| | Hint | Player | Journey |
| Reliever for the 2004 WS Red Sox | |
| Turn-of-the-century slugger who saved Cy Young's perfect game with a wall-crashing catch | |
| Nicknamed for the downcast appearance due to wearing his cap low | |
| HoF pitcher also known for powerful bat | |
| Pitched a combined no-hitter with Babe Ruth; recorded all 27 outs | |
| Mustachioed Cuban pitcher who twisted around completely in his delivery | |
| Slugging left fielder who played over a decade in Detroit | |
| Second baseman for the 2004 WS Red Sox | |
|