| Player | Nickname |
| George Herman Ruth | |
| Jay Hanna Dean | |
| Robert Moses Grove | |
| Harold Henry Reese | |
| Charles Arthur Vance | |
| Charles Augustus Nichols | |
| William Joseph Skowron | |
| Forrest Harrill Burgess | |
| Charles Benjamin Adams | |
| Charles Herbert Ruffing | |
| Paul Howard Trout | |
| Harry Seibold | |
| Grover Cleveland Alexander | |
| Dennis Ray Boyd | |
| Charles Gardner Radbourn | |
| Norman Thomas Stearnes | |
| John Wesley Powell | |
| William Arthur Cummings | |
| Edwin Donald Snider | |
| Raleigh Mackey | |
| Walter James Vincent Maranville | |
| Emil John Leonard | |
| Floyd Caves Herman | |
| Larry Wayne Jones | |
| Albert Walter Lyle | |
| Vernon Louis Gomez | |
| Leon Allen Goslin | |
| Frank Edwin McGraw | |
| Edward Charles Ford | |
| | Player | Nickname |
| Lynwood Thomas Rowe | |
| Paul Dee Dean | |
| James Leslie Vaughn | |
| James Timothy Grant | |
| Frederick Marberry | |
| Lewis Robert Wilson | |
| Elwin Charles Roe | |
| Johnny Leonard Roosevelt Martin | |
| Urban Clarence Faber | |
| Russel Earl Dent | |
| James Bentley Seymour | |
| John Henry Lloyd | |
| Harold Joseph Traynor | |
| George Lange Kelly | |
| Hazen Shirley Cuyler | |
| Lawrence Peter Berra | |
| Joseph Floyd Vaughan | |
| James Francis Galvin | |
| Covelli Royce Crisp | |
| Saturnino Orestes Armas Minoso | |
| Adrian Constantine Anson | |
| Leroy Robert Paige | |
| James Augustus Hunter | |
| James Thomas Bell | |
| William Hayward Wilson | |
| Albert Fred Schoendienst | |
| Denton True Young | |
| Eugene Franklin Hargrave | |
|