| Nickname | Player |
| Iron Horse | |
| Georgia Peach | |
| Wahoo | |
| Wee Willie | |
| Mad Dog | |
| The Barber | |
| Wizard of Oz | |
| The Meal Ticket | |
| Big Hurt | |
| Spaceman | |
| Ryan Express | |
| Big Train | |
| Double X | |
| The Silver Fox | |
| Knucksie | |
| Goofy | |
| Dominican Dandy | |
| Splendid Splinter | |
| | Nickname | Player |
| The Mayor | |
| Rapid Robert | |
| Oil Can | |
| Chairman of the Board | |
| The Crime Dog | |
| Blue Moon | |
| Pudge | |
| Prince Hal | |
| El Duque | |
| Stretch | |
| The Fordham Flash | |
| Home Run | |
| Stan The Man | |
| Vlad the Impaler | |
| Ducky | |
| Big Papi | |
| Pops | |
|