| Hint | Character | Performer |
| Previous Muppet's favorite singing duo seen in first season of The Muppet Show | |
| Miss Piggy's young rival who appeared in the third season of The Muppet Show | |
| Scientist on The Muppet Show | |
| Previous Muppet's assistant who constantly fell victim to his inventions | |
| 'Cute' rabbit on Jim Henson Hour | |
| Sarcastic prawn from Muppets Tonight | |
| Fraggle Rock character who sang the song 'Just a Dream Away.' Was only seen in the episode 'Gone But Not Forgotten.' | |
| Sesame Street cowboy with a lack of memory | |
| Sarcastic rodent who first appeared in Muppets Take Manhattan | |
| Cook who speaks mostly in jibberish. | |
| 'America's Friendliest Game Show Host' on Sesame Street | |
| Monster who sang with Alice Cooper on The Muppet Show | |
| Lemur on Bear in the Big Blue House | |
| Mouse on Bear in the Big Blue House | |
| Fraggle who can convince anyone to do anything with his trio of backup singers 'The Fragglettes' | |
| Fraggle who travels through 'outer space' and sends postcards about his discoveries | |
| Sesame Street character who lives in a trash can and dislikes having fun like the other residents of the street. | |
| Blue Sesame Street character who eats a lot, especially a certain sugary treat. | |
| Backup singers in the music number 'Mahna Mahna' | |
| Miss Piggy's dog | |
| Muppet Show Character who loves to explode things | |
| Rooster on Muppet Musicians of Bremen and later The Muppet Show | |
| Pig on 'Bay of Pigswatch' from Muppets Tonight | |
| Miss Piggy's biggest fan as seen on Muppet Family Christmas | |
| Sesame Street bovine who sang 'Proud to Be a Cow' | |