| Athlete 1 | College | Athlete 2 |
|---|
| Kirk Gibson (MLB) | |
| Orlando Pace (NFL) | |
| Al Horford (NBA) | |
| Eli Manning (NFL) | |
| Tyus Edney (NBA) | |
| Carl Yastrzemski (MLB) | |
| Frank Thomas (MLB) | |
| Marc Bulger (NFL) | |
| Phil Mickelson (Golf) | |
| Marty Turco (NHL) | |
| Peyton Manning (NFL) | |
| Ryan Leaf (NFL) | |
| Wes Welker (NFL) | |
| Mia Hamm (Soccer) | |
| David Robinson (NBA) | |
| Brad Hawpe (MLB) | |
| | Athlete 1 | College | Athlete 2 |
|---|
| Rashaan Salaam (NFL) | |
| Jim Brown (NFL) | |
| Chris Bosh (NBA) | |
| Ronnie Lott (NFL) | |
| Dominique Wilkins (NBA) | |
| Kevin Youkilis (MLB) | |
| Carlos Quentin (MLB) | |
| Mookie Blaylock (NBA) | |
| Rulon Gardner (Wrestling) | |
| David Price (MLB) | |
| Khalil Greene (MLB) | |
| Joey Porter (NFL) | |
| Paul Posluszny (NFL) | |
| Steve Prefontaine (Track) | |
| Jason Jennings (MLB) | |
| LaDainian Tomlinson (NFL) | |
|
MLB Teams 
NFL Teams 
Division-I Basketball
