| Former Name(s) (First Year Used) | Current Name | Current Division |
| Dial Square (1886) | |
| Small Heath Alliance (1875) | |
| Christ Church FC (1874) | |
| St. Domingo's FC (1878) | |
| Fulham St. Andrew's Church Sunday School FC (1879) | |
| Everton FC and Athletic Grounds Ltd (1892) | |
| St. Mark's (West Gorton) (1880); Ardwick AFC (1887) | |
| Newton Heath LYR FC (1878) | |
| Stoke Ramblers FC (1863) | |
| Sunderland District & Teachers AFC (1879) | |
| Hotspur FC (1882) | |
| West Bromwich Strollers (1878) | |
| Thames Ironworks FC (1895) | |
| St. Luke's FC (1877) | |
| Barnsley St. Peter's (1887) | |
| Riverside AFC (1899) | |
| Singers FC (1883) | |
| Leicester Fosse (1884) | |