| Teams | Catchers | Total War (2000-2012) |
| Twins | |
| Yankees | |
| Rangers, Marlins, Tigers, Yankees, Astros, Rangers, Nationals | |
| Indians, Red Sox, Tigers | |
| Pirates, Athletics, Cubs, Brewers, Royals | |
| Braves | |
| Red Sox | |
| Cardinals | |
| Dodgers, Yankees | |
| Athletics, Padres, Orioles, Reds, Rockies | |
| Twins, Giants, White Sox | |
| Angels, Rangers | |
| Dodgers, Marlins, Mets, Nationals, Marlins | |
| Braves, Orioles, Red Sox | |
| Phillies | |
| | Teams | Catchers | Total War (2000-2012) |
| Giants | |
| Royals, Astros, Rockies, Blue Jays, Orioles, Rays, Brewers | |
| Orioles | |
| Diamondbacks | |
| Athletics, Nationals | |
| Indians | |
| Rockies, Angels | |
| Orioles, White Sox, Marlins, Rockies, Devil Rays | |
| Phillies, Dodgers | |
| Angels, Blue Jays, Giants, Rangers | |
| Pirates, Twins | |
| Red Sox, Indians, Rays, Red Sox, Mets | |
| Reds, Royals, Cardinals | |
| Cubs, Rangers | |
| Dodgers, Pirates, Padres, Reds, Red Sox, Braves | |
|