| Stolen Item | U.S. State |
| The Santa Fe Trail | |
| A crystal chandelier from The Breakers | |
| The Boll Weevil Monument | |
| The Painted Desert | |
| The 'American Gothic' House | |
| The launching pad from Cape Canaveral | |
| America's first log cabin | |
| The original manuscript of 'The Star Spangled Banner' | |
| The International Peace Garden | |
| The headwaters of the Mississippi River | |
| The original Model T Ford | |
| The President's helicopter | |
| The end of the Oregon Trail | |
| The prize-winning dairy cow | |
| The Liberty Bell | |
| All the lobster pots in the state | |
| The entire year's harvest of maple syrup | |
| Thomas Edison's Menlo Park laboratory | |
| The wind gauge from Mt. Washington | |
| All the ten-gallon hats | |
| The finish flag from the Indy 500 | |
| The secret formula for Kodiak bear repellant | |
| All the river steamboats | |
| The stage from the Grand Ole Opry | |
| All the snow from Sun Valley | |
| The herd of Chincoteague ponies | |