| Hint | Character |
| alcoholic redhead | |
| art school dropout | |
| sarcastic joker who loves messing with Dwight | |
| worlds best boss, according to a mug | |
| crossword puzzle lover | |
| diva who loves pink | |
| orphan secretary who is just plain weird according to michael | |
| nickname is Nard Dog | |
| young rebel who's middle name is Bailey | |
| dated Michael and has a candle shop | |
| | Hint | Character |
| nerd who has a beet farm | |
| the gay one | |
| the cookie monster | |
| works in warehouse and dated kelly | |
| the plump lady who is married | |
| the one perfect for Michael | |
| an old creepy guy who has a crazy past | |
| the one who is put down and the one Michael hates | |
| the crazy cat lady who has a thing for Dwight | |
|