| Hint | Name |
| 1st Heisman Trophy winner, 1st NFL draft pick | |
| 8 time NBA finalist, 1958 NCAA tournament MVP | |
| Winner of 5 straight Wimbledon titles | |
| NHL Hall of Famer, winner of 5 Norris Trophies | |
| Coached Alabama football to 6 national titles | |
| RB, led NFL in rushing yardage 8 times | |
| Red Sox 3B, 5-time American League batting champ | |
| Won 4 Super Bowls as the Steelers' QB | |
| Yankees catcher, 3-time American League MVP | |
| Member of the 500 HR club, 2-time National League MVP | |
| | Hint | Name |
| Set single season NFL passing TD's record with 50 | |
| 3-time Wimbledon champion | |
| Reds catcher, 1970, 1972 National League MVP | |
| Winner of 3 Stanley Cups and 4 Vezina Trophies | |
| 2-time NBA champion, former U.S. Senator | |
| 'Miracle On Ice' coach | |
| 5-time NBA All-Star, Member of original 'Dream Team' | |
| All-time winningest coach in NHL history | |
| Led Celtics to 3 NBA championships | |
| Coached Patriots to 3 Super Bowl wins | |
|