| Year (School) | Maxwell Winner | Heisman Winner |
| 1971 (Cornell) | |
| 1972 (Michigan State) | |
| 1974 (Temple) | |
| 1977 (Notre Dame) | |
| 1978 (Penn State) | |
| 1980 (Pittsburgh) | |
| 1985 (Iowa) | |
| 1987 (Syracuse) | |
| 1989 (Indiana) | |
| 1994 (Penn State) | |
| | Year (School) | Maxwell Winner | Heisman Winner |
| 1997 (Tennessee) | |
| 2000 (Purdue) | |
| 2001 (Miami, Fla.) | |
| 2002 (Penn State) | |
| 2003 (Mississippi) | |
| 2004 (Oklahoma) | |
| 2005 (Texas) | |
| 2006 (Notre Dame) | |
| 2008 (Florida) | |
|