| Hint | Player | #HRs |
| All Time Greatest? | |
| John Goodman? | |
| Steroid Finger Pointer? | |
| Active in the Windy City? | |
| Kingdome? | |
| Fastest Bat Motion Before Swing? | |
| Was Black, Now White? | |
| 'The Man'? | |
| Half the Bash? | |
| Outfield Relay? | |
| Mr October? | |
| Cleveland-Philadelphia-Chicago-LA-Minneapolis? | |
| Mr 400? | |
| The Say Hey Kid? | |
| Phantic? | |
| Yom Kippur? | |
| 'Puff' aka Graig Nettles? | |
| Stormin' Norm Cash? | |
| Del Got It? | |
| Celebrity Softball Extraordinaire? | |
| | Hint | Player | #HRs |
| The Cove? | |
| Best Knuckleball Ever? | |
| 'Master Melvin' Otter? | |
| 1958 Giants Rookie of the Year? | |
| Polish Sox? | |
| 90% of the game is half mental? | |
| Sweet-Swinging Billy Williams? | |
| 'Pops' Pittsburgh Pirate Will? | |
| Last Person You Would Want to Fight? | |
| Rocky Colavito? | |
| Tomahawk Chop? | |
| Youngest to Reach 500 HRs --Bo Sox? | |
| 3rd Base GG? | |
| Ralph Kiner? | |
| Minnesota Outdoorsman? | |
| Hippies Running Bases? | |
| Richest Contract Ever? | |
| Wes Favorite Punch Line? | |
| Shares same last name as Pro Wrestler 'Fit'? | |
| Chopper 2 Hopper Joe Crede? | |
|