| Hint | Wrestler |
| Dusty Rhodes' manager | |
| Manager of the Bashams | |
| Former Commentator and Assistant Raw GM | |
| Host of the VIP Lounge | |
| Black Machismo | |
| His former tag partner; sounds like a character from Rocky | |
| Dominating former TNA Women's wrestler | |
| Member of the Full Blooded Italians in the original ECW | |
| Original ECW wrestler; sounds like a Woody Woodpecker character | |
| Tough Enough Season 1 Winner | |
| Big wrestling star in Japan and MMA Fighter | |
| Host of a Late Night style show on ECW | |
| New ECW commentator | |
| Stampede Wrestling star in the 60s & 70s | |
| 'The Madman From the Sudan' | |
| Scott Steiner's former TNA manager | |
| Member of Extreme Exposé and Team Lay-Cool | |
| ROH wrestler and former Tough Enough contestant | |
| Independent wrestler with a blaxploitation gimmick | |
| 'Mr. 630' | |
| ROH Manager of The Rottweilers | |
| 'Iceman' | |
| NXT Season 1 Rookie 'The South Beach Party Boy' | |
| NXT Season 1 Rookie 'A-List' | |
| NXT Season 1 Rookie; He is the product! | |
| NXT Season 2 Rookie 'Showtime' | |
| NXT Season 2 Rookie paired with Zack Ryder | |