MLB 'HOF-ish' Non-HOF Players

Random Sports or MLB Quiz

Can you name the MLB non-HOF players most similar to each HOFer by similarity score?

Quiz not verified by Sporcle

 plays        
How to Play
Four HOFers have two non-HOFers with the same similarity score (separated by commas). Six HOF players have no non-HOFers in their top 10 list of similar players (BB Reference doesn't list more than 10): Cap Anson, Dan Brouthers, Nap Lajoie, Tris Speaker, Honus Wagner, and Paul Waner. Years listed are the first and last of the non-HOFer's career (or just the first if they are active). Team listed is the one on which the non-HOFer played the most games. See first comment for team/franchise abbreviations.
Score 0/200 Timer 20:00
HOFerNon-HOFerTeam, Years
Hank AaronSFG 1986-2007
Pete AlexanderATL 1986-2008
Roberto AlomarNYY 1995-
Luis AparicioCLE 1989-
Luke ApplingCHC 1891-1911, CLE 1989-
Richie AshburnLAD 1981-1997
Earl AverillCHW 1997-
Home Run BakerPHI 1928-1939
Dave BancroftNYY 1910-1927
Ernie BanksFLA 1988-2009
Jake BeckleyCHC 1885-1903
Johnny BenchNYM 1992-2007
Chief BenderBOS 1915-1929
Yogi BerraOAK 1997-
Bert BlylevenCHW 1963-1989
Wade BoggsCHC 1885-1903
Jim BottomleySFG 1986-2000
Lou BoudreauNYG 1907-1920
Roger BresnahanNYY 1929-1940
George BrettARI 1990-2008
Lou BrockMON 1979-2002
Mordecai BrownCHW 1905-1920
Jim BunningDET 1963-1979
Jesse BurkettNYG 1887-1903
Roy CampanellaATL 1992-2006
Rod CarewCHC 1885-1903
Max CareyBOS 1929-1948
Steve CarltonBOS 1984-2007
Gary CarterDET 1977-1995
Orlando CepedaMON 1985-2004
Frank ChanceSTL 1915-1929
Jack ChesbroCHC 1930-1945
Fred ClarkeNYG 1887-1903
John ClarksonCIN 1881-1894
Roberto ClementeCIN 1958-1975
Ty CobbCIN 1963-1986
Mickey CochraneSTL 1940-1957, NYY 1969-1979
Eddie CollinsCHC 1891-1911
Jimmy CollinsSLB 1912-1924
Earle CombsNYG 1887-1899
Roger ConnorCHC 1885-1903
Stan CoveleskiBOS 1915-1929
Sam CrawfordCHC 1885-1903
Joe CroninCIN 1986-2004
Kiki CuylerCHC 1885-1903
George DavisCHC 1891-1911
Andre DawsonPIT 1973-1991
Dizzy DeanHOU 2001-
Ed DelahantyCHC 1885-1903
Bill DickeyNYY 1995-
Joe DiMaggioCOL 1989-2005
Larry DobySTL 1998-
Bobby DoerrSLB 1941-1955
Don DrysdaleBAL 1957-1973
Hugh DuffyCHC 1885-1903
Dennis EckersleySTL 1955-1975
Johnny EversPIT 1897-1909
Buck EwingBUF 1879-1892
Red FaberNYY 1909-1933
Bob FellerDET 1977-1994
Rick FerrellWAS 1884-1912
Rollie FingersATL 1969-1988
Carlton FiskTEX 1991-
Elmer FlickWAS 1894-1906
Whitey FordBSN 1882-1892
Nellie FoxBOS 1929-1948
Jimmie FoxxBOS 1993-2011
HOFerNon-HOFerTeam, Years
Frankie FrischPHI 1887-1907
Pud GalvinNYU 1871-1887
Lou GehrigBOS 1993-2011
Charlie GehringerNYY 1995-
Bob GibsonDET 1977-1994
Lefty GomezNYY 1942-1954
Joe GordonSEA 1992-2005
Goose GoslinPIT 1968-1985
Rich GossageSTL 1955-1975
Hank GreenbergHOU 1999-
Clark GriffithNYG 1925-1943
Burleigh GrimesCIN 1881-1894
Lefty GroveATL 1987-2008
Tony GwynnPIT 1968-1985
Chick HafeySLB 1915-1929
Jesse HainesNYG 1925-1943
Billy HamiltonCIN 1888-1902
Gabby HartnettNYY 1995-
Harry HeilmannPIT 1968-1985
Rickey HendersonHOU 1988-2007
Billy HermanWSH 1925-1941
Harry HooperCHC 1897-1913
Rogers HornsbySFG 1992-2008
Waite HoytDET 1912-1926
Carl HubbellBSN 1882-1892
Catfish HunterBOS 1964-1982
Reggie JacksonFLA 1988-2009
Travis JacksonTEX 2000-
Fergie JenkinsMIN 1959-1983
Hughie JenningsWSH 1933-1947
Walter JohnsonATL 1986-2008
Addie JossCHC 1880-1887
Al KalineCHW 1980-2001
Tim KeefeATL 1986-2008
Willie KeelerNYG 1887-1903
George KellDET 1952-1966
Joe KelleyDET 1912-1925
High Pockets KellyHOU 1966-1984
King KellyBUF 1879-1892
Harmon KillebrewCLE 1991-
Ralph KinerNYM 1983-1999
Chuck KleinCHW 1997-
Sandy KoufaxNYY 1975-1988
Tony LazzeriSLB 1941-1955
Bob LemonBSN 1889-1899
Freddie LindstromSLB 1915-1927
Ernie LombardiSTL 1940-1957
Ted LyonsPAA 1887-1901
Mickey MantleCLE 1991-
Heinie ManushCHC 1885-1903
Rabbit MaranvilleCLE 1989-
Juan MarichalBSN 1882-1892
Rube MarquardCHC 1929-1942
Eddie MathewsATL 1993-
Christy MathewsonATL 1986-2008
Willie MaysSEA 1989-2010
Bill MazeroskiKCR 1973-1990
Tommy McCarthyBSN 1893-1905
Willie McCoveyATL 1986-2004
Joe McGinnityBSN 1882-1892
Bid McPheeCHC 1891-1911
Joe MedwickPIT 1968-1985
Johnny MizeMON 1990-2008
Paul MolitorCIN 1958-1975
Joe MorganDET 1977-1995
Eddie MurrayTEX 1986-2005
Stan MusialTEX 1986-2005
HOFerNon-HOFerTeam, Years
Hal NewhouserNYY 1913-1927
Kid NicholsATL 1986-2008
Phil NiekroCHW 1963-1989
Jim O'RourkeCHC 1885-1903
Mel OttFLA 1988-2009
Jim PalmerBAL 1991-2008
Herb PennockNYG 1925-1943
Tony PerezCHW 1980-2001
Gaylord PerryCHW 1963-1989
Kirby PuckettNYY 1982-1995
Old Hoss RadbournCBL 1878-1887
Pee Wee ReeseSTL 1996-
Jim RiceMON 1985-2004
Sam RiceCHC 1885-1903
Cal RipkenHOU 1988-2007
Eppa RixeySLB 1897-1912
Phil RizzutoNYG 1909-1922
Robin RobertsMIN 1959-1983
Brooks RobinsonNYM 1963-1985
Frank RobinsonSEA 1989-2010
Jackie RobinsonPIT 1922-1934
Edd RoushDET 1912-1925
Red RuffingPAA 1887-1901
Amos RusieDET 1902-1915
Babe RuthSFG 1986-2007
Nolan RyanBOS 1984-2007
Ryne SandbergDET 1977-1995
Ray SchalkCLE 1921-1942
Mike SchmidtCHC 1989-2007
Red SchoendienstTOR 1983-2001
Tom SeaverATL 1987-2008
Joe SewellWSH 1925-1941
Al SimmonsPIT 1973-1991
George SislerWSH 1915-1934, CHC 1885-1903
Enos SlaughterWSH 1939-1960
Ozzie SmithOAK 1964-1983
Duke SniderBOS 1987-2004
Warren SpahnATL 1986-2008
Willie StargellTOR 1993-2009
Bruce SutterCLE 1982-2000
Don SuttonATL 1986-2008
Bill TerryNYY 1982-1995
Sam ThompsonNYG 1887-1899
Joe TinkerCHW 1985-2000
Pie TraynorDET 1912-1925
Dazzy VanceBAL 1959-1977
Arky VaughanWSH 1925-1941
Rube WaddellCHC 1908-1921
Bobby WallaceCIN 1970-1988
Ed WalshPIT 1898-1910
Lloyd WanerKCR 1976-1994
Monte Ward (as batter)BSN 1890-1907
Monte Ward (as pitcher)PIT 1899-1911
Mickey WelchCIN 1881-1894
Zack WheatPIT 1968-1985
Hoyt WilhelmSTL 1955-1975
Billy WilliamsARI 1990-2008, PIT 1973-1991
Ted WilliamsBOS 1993-2011
Vic WillisDET 1902-1915
Hack WilsonBSN 1930-1940
Dave WinfieldTEX 1986-2005
Early WynnATL 1987-2008
Carl YastrzemskiTEX 1986-2005
Cy YoungATL 1986-2008
Ross YoungsBOS 1897-1906
Robin YountHOU 1988-2007

Friend Scores


  Player Best Score Plays Last Played
You You haven't played this game yet.

You Might Also Like...

Extras