Sports / MLB 'HOF-ish' Non-HOF Players

Random Sports or MLB Quiz

Can you name the MLB non-HOF players most similar to each HOFer by similarity score?

Quiz not verified by Sporcle

How to Play
Challenge
Share
Tweet
Four HOFers have two non-HOFers with the same similarity score (separated by commas). Six HOF players have no non-HOFers in their top 10 list of similar players (BB Reference doesn't list more than 10): Cap Anson, Dan Brouthers, Nap Lajoie, Tris Speaker, Honus Wagner, and Paul Waner. Years listed are the first and last of the non-HOFer's career (or just the first if they are active). Team listed is the one on which the non-HOFer played the most games. See first comment for team/franchise abbreviations.
Score 0/200 Timer 20:00
HOFerNon-HOFerTeam, Years
Hank AaronSFG 1986-2007
Pete AlexanderATL 1986-2008
Roberto AlomarNYY 1995-
Luis AparicioCLE 1989-
Luke ApplingCHC 1891-1911, CLE 1989-
Richie AshburnLAD 1981-1997
Earl AverillCHW 1997-
Home Run BakerPHI 1928-1939
Dave BancroftNYY 1910-1927
Ernie BanksFLA 1988-2009
Jake BeckleyCHC 1885-1903
Johnny BenchNYM 1992-2007
Chief BenderBOS 1915-1929
Yogi BerraOAK 1997-
Bert BlylevenCHW 1963-1989
Wade BoggsCHC 1885-1903
Jim BottomleySFG 1986-2000
Lou BoudreauNYG 1907-1920
Roger BresnahanNYY 1929-1940
George BrettARI 1990-2008
Lou BrockMON 1979-2002
Mordecai BrownCHW 1905-1920
Jim BunningDET 1963-1979
Jesse BurkettNYG 1887-1903
Roy CampanellaATL 1992-2006
Rod CarewCHC 1885-1903
Max CareyBOS 1929-1948
Steve CarltonBOS 1984-2007
Gary CarterDET 1977-1995
Orlando CepedaMON 1985-2004
Frank ChanceSTL 1915-1929
Jack ChesbroCHC 1930-1945
Fred ClarkeNYG 1887-1903
John ClarksonCIN 1881-1894
Roberto ClementeCIN 1958-1975
Ty CobbCIN 1963-1986
Mickey CochraneSTL 1940-1957, NYY 1969-1979
Eddie CollinsCHC 1891-1911
Jimmy CollinsSLB 1912-1924
Earle CombsNYG 1887-1899
Roger ConnorCHC 1885-1903
Stan CoveleskiBOS 1915-1929
Sam CrawfordCHC 1885-1903
Joe CroninCIN 1986-2004
Kiki CuylerCHC 1885-1903
George DavisCHC 1891-1911
Andre DawsonPIT 1973-1991
Dizzy DeanHOU 2001-
Ed DelahantyCHC 1885-1903
Bill DickeyNYY 1995-
Joe DiMaggioCOL 1989-2005
Larry DobySTL 1998-
Bobby DoerrSLB 1941-1955
Don DrysdaleBAL 1957-1973
Hugh DuffyCHC 1885-1903
Dennis EckersleySTL 1955-1975
Johnny EversPIT 1897-1909
Buck EwingBUF 1879-1892
Red FaberNYY 1909-1933
Bob FellerDET 1977-1994
Rick FerrellWAS 1884-1912
Rollie FingersATL 1969-1988
Carlton FiskTEX 1991-
Elmer FlickWAS 1894-1906
Whitey FordBSN 1882-1892
Nellie FoxBOS 1929-1948
Jimmie FoxxBOS 1993-2011
HOFerNon-HOFerTeam, Years
Frankie FrischPHI 1887-1907
Pud GalvinNYU 1871-1887
Lou GehrigBOS 1993-2011
Charlie GehringerNYY 1995-
Bob GibsonDET 1977-1994
Lefty GomezNYY 1942-1954
Joe GordonSEA 1992-2005
Goose GoslinPIT 1968-1985
Rich GossageSTL 1955-1975
Hank GreenbergHOU 1999-
Clark GriffithNYG 1925-1943
Burleigh GrimesCIN 1881-1894
Lefty GroveATL 1987-2008
Tony GwynnPIT 1968-1985
Chick HafeySLB 1915-1929
Jesse HainesNYG 1925-1943
Billy HamiltonCIN 1888-1902
Gabby HartnettNYY 1995-
Harry HeilmannPIT 1968-1985
Rickey HendersonHOU 1988-2007
Billy HermanWSH 1925-1941
Harry HooperCHC 1897-1913
Rogers HornsbySFG 1992-2008
Waite HoytDET 1912-1926
Carl HubbellBSN 1882-1892
Catfish HunterBOS 1964-1982
Reggie JacksonFLA 1988-2009
Travis JacksonTEX 2000-
Fergie JenkinsMIN 1959-1983
Hughie JenningsWSH 1933-1947
Walter JohnsonATL 1986-2008
Addie JossCHC 1880-1887
Al KalineCHW 1980-2001
Tim KeefeATL 1986-2008
Willie KeelerNYG 1887-1903
George KellDET 1952-1966
Joe KelleyDET 1912-1925
High Pockets KellyHOU 1966-1984
King KellyBUF 1879-1892
Harmon KillebrewCLE 1991-
Ralph KinerNYM 1983-1999
Chuck KleinCHW 1997-
Sandy KoufaxNYY 1975-1988
Tony LazzeriSLB 1941-1955
Bob LemonBSN 1889-1899
Freddie LindstromSLB 1915-1927
Ernie LombardiSTL 1940-1957
Ted LyonsPAA 1887-1901
Mickey MantleCLE 1991-
Heinie ManushCHC 1885-1903
Rabbit MaranvilleCLE 1989-
Juan MarichalBSN 1882-1892
Rube MarquardCHC 1929-1942
Eddie MathewsATL 1993-
Christy MathewsonATL 1986-2008
Willie MaysSEA 1989-2010
Bill MazeroskiKCR 1973-1990
Tommy McCarthyBSN 1893-1905
Willie McCoveyATL 1986-2004
Joe McGinnityBSN 1882-1892
Bid McPheeCHC 1891-1911
Joe MedwickPIT 1968-1985
Johnny MizeMON 1990-2008
Paul MolitorCIN 1958-1975
Joe MorganDET 1977-1995
Eddie MurrayTEX 1986-2005
Stan MusialTEX 1986-2005
HOFerNon-HOFerTeam, Years
Hal NewhouserNYY 1913-1927
Kid NicholsATL 1986-2008
Phil NiekroCHW 1963-1989
Jim O'RourkeCHC 1885-1903
Mel OttFLA 1988-2009
Jim PalmerBAL 1991-2008
Herb PennockNYG 1925-1943
Tony PerezCHW 1980-2001
Gaylord PerryCHW 1963-1989
Kirby PuckettNYY 1982-1995
Old Hoss RadbournCBL 1878-1887
Pee Wee ReeseSTL 1996-
Jim RiceMON 1985-2004
Sam RiceCHC 1885-1903
Cal RipkenHOU 1988-2007
Eppa RixeySLB 1897-1912
Phil RizzutoNYG 1909-1922
Robin RobertsMIN 1959-1983
Brooks RobinsonNYM 1963-1985
Frank RobinsonSEA 1989-2010
Jackie RobinsonPIT 1922-1934
Edd RoushDET 1912-1925
Red RuffingPAA 1887-1901
Amos RusieDET 1902-1915
Babe RuthSFG 1986-2007
Nolan RyanBOS 1984-2007
Ryne SandbergDET 1977-1995
Ray SchalkCLE 1921-1942
Mike SchmidtCHC 1989-2007
Red SchoendienstTOR 1983-2001
Tom SeaverATL 1987-2008
Joe SewellWSH 1925-1941
Al SimmonsPIT 1973-1991
George SislerWSH 1915-1934, CHC 1885-1903
Enos SlaughterWSH 1939-1960
Ozzie SmithOAK 1964-1983
Duke SniderBOS 1987-2004
Warren SpahnATL 1986-2008
Willie StargellTOR 1993-2009
Bruce SutterCLE 1982-2000
Don SuttonATL 1986-2008
Bill TerryNYY 1982-1995
Sam ThompsonNYG 1887-1899
Joe TinkerCHW 1985-2000
Pie TraynorDET 1912-1925
Dazzy VanceBAL 1959-1977
Arky VaughanWSH 1925-1941
Rube WaddellCHC 1908-1921
Bobby WallaceCIN 1970-1988
Ed WalshPIT 1898-1910
Lloyd WanerKCR 1976-1994
Monte Ward (as batter)BSN 1890-1907
Monte Ward (as pitcher)PIT 1899-1911
Mickey WelchCIN 1881-1894
Zack WheatPIT 1968-1985
Hoyt WilhelmSTL 1955-1975
Billy WilliamsARI 1990-2008, PIT 1973-1991
Ted WilliamsBOS 1993-2011
Vic WillisDET 1902-1915
Hack WilsonBSN 1930-1940
Dave WinfieldTEX 1986-2005
Early WynnATL 1987-2008
Carl YastrzemskiTEX 1986-2005
Cy YoungATL 1986-2008
Ross YoungsBOS 1897-1906
Robin YountHOU 1988-2007

You're not logged in!

Compare scores with friends on all Sporcle quizzes.
Sign Up with Email
OR
Log In

You Might Also Like...

Show Comments

Extras


Your Account Isn't Verified!

In order to create a playlist on Sporcle, you need to verify the email address you used during registration. Go to your Sporcle Settings to finish the process.