Suppose the MLB Hall of Fame was based solely on career WAR, but had the same number of players. Which non-HOF players would make it in and which HOF players would be booted out?
There are currently 205 players in the HOF (excluding primarily Negro League players and individuals elected as non-players). Of the top 205 players in career WAR (offense + defense + pitching) who played no later than 2005, 66 are not in the HOF. Name these 66 non-HOFers and the 66 actual HOFers with the fewest career WAR who would be booted out to make room. Players are listed with the team/franchise on which they played the most games, the first and last years of their MLB career, and their career WAR. Data runs from 1876-2005. See first comment for team/franchise abbreviations. Press F11 if you can't see the whole quiz.