| Clue | Wrestler |
| once squashed Jake Robert's snake | |
| Holiday mascot, competed in the APA Bar Room Brawl at Vengeance 2003 | |
| 'Latino Heat' | |
| 'The Rated R Superstar' | |
| Member of DOA | |
| Mexican wrestler | |
| Mexican wrestler | |
| Twin wrestlerr | |
| NXT Season 2 competitor | |
| Member of the ECW New Breed | |
| | Clue | Wrestler |
| Former Tag Team Champion; part of the Colon family | |
| Former Raw General Manager | |
| Short lived Smackdown wrestler, was managed by Vickie Guerrero | |
| 'The Cat' | |
| Former Light Heavyweight Champion, managed by Lita | |
| Eric Bischoff's mentally handicapped nephew! | |
| Former Tag Team Champion, Suspended for drug use | |
| Broke Zack Ryder's heart | |
| Competed in the opening match of the inaugural Wrestlemania | |
| Member of the Corre | |
|