| Details | Player |
| Manchester United (56, 58) | |
| Wolves (56, 57, 58) | |
| Blackpool (56, 57) | |
| Manchester United (57) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (57, 58, 61) | |
| Fulham (57, 58, 61) | |
| Manchester United (58) | |
| Burnley (58) | |
| S****horpe (59) | |
| Manchester United (60, 61, 63, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 71) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (60) | |
| Chelsea (60) Tottenham Hotspur (61, 62, 63, 64, 68) | |
| Burnley (61) | |
| Manchester United (62, 63, 64, 65, 66) Manchester City (73) | |
| West Ham United (64, 66, 68, 70, 71, 72, 73) | |
| Cardiff City (65) | |
| Sunderland (65) | |
| Everton (66, 67, 68, 70) | |
| Leicester City (66) Stoke City (70, 72) | |
| West Ham United (66, 67, 70) | |
| Manchester United (66) | |
| Celtic (67, 68, 69) | |
| Celtic (67, 68) | |
| Manchester United (67, 68, 69, 71) | |
| Leeds United (68, 69) | |
| Manchester City (69, 70, 71) | |
| West Ham United (69) | |
| Leeds United (69, 73, 74) | |
| Leeds United (70, 71) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (71) | |
| Rangers (72) | |
| Leeds United (72) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (73, 75, 85) | |
| Derby County (75) | |
| Leeds United (75) | |
| Queen’s Park Rangers (75) | |
| Liverpool (76) | |
| Liverpool (77) | |
| Liverpool (77) | |
| West Ham United (77, 79, 81) | |
| Nottingham Forest (77, 78, 80) Southampton (85) Derby County (87, 89) | |
| Liverpool (77) | |
| Leeds United (77) Manchester United (79) | |
| Livepool (78, 79, 80, 81, 83, 86) | |
| Liverpool (78) | |
| Nottingham Forest (78) | |
| Nottingham Forest (79, 80) | |
| Arsenal (79) | |
| | Details | Player |
| Liverpool (80) | |
| Arsenal (80) | |
| Nottingham Forest (80) | |
| Ipswich Town (81) | |
| Manchester United (81, 83, 84, 85, 87) | |
| Manchester United (81) | |
| Ipswich Town (81) | |
| Aberdeen (83) Manchester United (84) | |
| Liverpool (83, 84, 85, 86) | |
| Manchester United (83) | |
| Celtic (84) | |
| Manchester United (84) | |
| Everton (85) | |
| Everton (85, 88) | |
| Everton (85) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (89, 90, 91) | |
| Liverpool (87, 89) | |
| Manchester United (87) Aston Villa (90, 91, 93) | |
| Liverpool (87) | |
| Rangers (87) | |
| Celtic (89) | |
| Liverpool (89) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (90) | |
| Nottingham Forest (90) | |
| Aston Villa (90) | |
| Manchester United (91) | |
| Liverpool (91) | |
| Manchester United (91) | |
| Rangers (91) | |
| Manchester United (92, 93, 97) | |
| Arsenal (92) | |
| Manchester United (93, 94, 96) | |
| Manchester United (93, 97, 99, 07, 09) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (94) | |
| Newcastle United (94) | |
| Leeds United (95) | |
| Blackburn Rovers (95) Newcastle United (96, 97) | |
| Arsenal (95) | |
| Manchester United (96) | |
| Middlesbrough (96) | |
| Arsenal (96) | |
| Liverpool (96) | |
| Rangers (96) Chelsea (98) | |
| Arsenal (97, 98) | |
| Chelsea (97) | |
| Manchester United (97, 98, 99, 00, 01) | |
| Liverpool (98, 01, 02) | |
| Chelsea (98, 00) | |
| | Details | Player |
| Arsenal (98) | |
| Arsenal (98) | |
| Manchester United (99, 00) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (99) | |
| Manchester United (99) | |
| Arsenal (99) | |
| Manchester United (99) | |
| Manchester United (99) | |
| Arsenal (00, 01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06) | |
| Manchester United (00) | |
| Celtic (01) | |
| Manchester United (01) | |
| Liverpool (01) | |
| Liverpool (01, 05, 07, 08, 09) | |
| Manchester United (02, 04) | |
| Arsenal (02, 04) | |
| Manchester United (02) | |
| Liverpool (02) | |
| Chelsea (03) | |
| Manchester United (04, 07, 08, 09, 11, 12) | |
| Chelsea (04) | |
| Manchester United (04, 05, 06, 07, 08) | |
| Liverpool (04) | |
| Chelsea (04, 05, 06, 08, 09) | |
| Chelsea (04, 05, 06, 07, 08, 09, 10) | |
| Chelsea (05, 06, 09) | |
| Chelsea (05) | |
| Chelsea (05, 07) | |
| Liverpool (05) | |
| Liverpool (05) | |
| Chelsea (05, 07) | |
| Arsenal (06) | |
| Arsenal (07, 08, 09, 10) | |
| Tottenham Hotspur (07) | |
| Arsenal (07), Manchester United (12) | |
| Manchester United (07) | |
| Liverpool (08, 09) | |
| Arsenal (08) | |
| Chelsea (08) | |
| Manchester United (08, 09) | |
| Manchester United (08) | |
| Arsenal (09) | |
| Sunderland (10) | |
| Liverpool (11) | |
| Manchester City (11, 12) | |
| Manchester United (11) | |
| Manchester City (12) | |
| Manchester City (12) | |
| Nominated while playing in Italy | |
| Nominated while playing in Germany | |
| Nominated while playing in France | |
| Nominated while playing in France | |
| Nominated while playing in Spain | |
| Nominated while playing in Italy and France | |
|