| Hint | Athlete | Team |
| I was the second player selected in the 2009 NBA draft by my team | |
| I recently signed a contracted to become the starting CF on the North Side | |
| I am a starting catcher, and have a very long last name | |
| I play very well, despite being a backup goalie | |
| I missed a game winning field goal, and then injured my leg in OT of the 2010 Outback Bowl | |
| I am on my current team for the second time, backing up a big man | |
| I had a strong rookie season, but struggled my second season | |
| I tossed a perfect game on July 23, 2009 | |
| | Hint | Athlete | Team |
| I was the first of 2 players selected by my team from Duke the year I was drafted | |
| I am the starting point card at Welsh-Ryan Arena | |
| I hail from Japan, struggled throughout 2009 | |
| I have been on the losing end of the Stanley Cup in 2008 and 2009 | |
| I quickly became a fan favorite in my rookie season playing 3rd base | |
| I have a long last name, and finished the 2009 season as my QBs favorite target | |
| I have been the starting QB for my team for 1 season | |
|