| Player, position, team(s) | Country of birth | Regional hint |
| Raul Allegre (K) Giants, Super Bowl XXI | |
| Robert Bailey (CB) Cowboys, Super Bowl XXX; Ravens, Super Bowl XXXV | |
| Mitch Berger (P) Steelers, Super Bowl XLIII | |
| Rohan Davey (QB) Patriots, Super Bowls XXXVIII, XXXIX | |
| Dan Federkeil (OT) Colts, Super Bowl XLI | |
| Roy Gerela (K) Steelers, Super Bowls IX, X, XIII | |
| Ted Hendricks (LB) Colts, Super Bowl V; Raiders, Super Bowls XI, XV, XVIII | |
| Efren Herrera (K) Cowboys, Super Bowl XII | |
| Sean Jones (DE) Packers, Super Bowl XXXI | |
| Allan Kennedy (OT) 49ers, Super Bowls XVI, XIX | |
| Eddie Murray (K) Cowboys, Super Bowl XXVIII | |
| Mark Rypien (QB) Redskins, Super Bowls XXII, XXVI | |
| Tyrone Williams (WR) Cowboys, Super Bowl XXVIII | |
| Klaus Wilmsmeyer (P) 49ers, Super Bowl XXIX | |
| Mark Adickes (G) Redskins, Super Bowl XXVI | |
| Bruce Collie (G/OT) 49ers, Super Bowls XXIII, XXIV | |
| Harald Hasselbach (DE) Broncos, Super Bowls XXXII, XXXIII | |
| Domenik Hixon (WR) Giants, Super Bowls XLII, XLVI | |
| Markus Koch (DE) Redskins, Super Bowl XXII | |
| Scott McCready (WR) Patriots, Super Bowl XXXVI | |
| Jamar Nesbit (G) Saints, Super Bowl XLIV | |
| Jan Stenerud (K) Chiefs, Super Bowl IV | |
| Lawrence Tynes (K) Giants, Super Bowl XLII | |
| Osi Umenyiora (DE) Giants, Super Bowls XLII, XLVI | |
| Ray Wersching (K) 49ers, Super Bowls XVI, XIX | |
| Riki Ellison (LB) 49ers, Super Bowls XIX, XXIII, XXIV | |
| Spencer Folau (OT) Ravens, Super Bowl XXXV | |
| Chris Kemoeatu (G) Steelers, Super Bowls XL, XLIII | |
| Freddy Keiaho (LB) Colts, Super Bowl XLI | |
| Todd Lyght (CB) Rams, Super Bowl XXXIV | |
| Bobby Singh (G) Rams, Super Bowl XXXIV | |
| David Jones (C) Redskins, Super Bowl XXII | |
| Hines Ward (WR) Steelers, Super Bowls XL, XLIII | |
| Garo Yepremian (K) Dolphins, Super Bowls VII, VIII | |
| Roman Oben (OT) Buccaneers, Super Bowl XXXVII | |
| Martín Gramática (K) Buccaneers, Super Bowl XXXVII | |