| Clue | Player |
| Backup QB New York Giants | |
| Middle Linebacker San Francisco 49ers | |
| Kicker New England Patriots | |
| Starting Running Back St. Louis Rams | |
| Kicker Kansas City Chiefs | |
| Right Tackle New Orleans Saints | |
| Center Chicago Bears | |
| Starting QB Indianapolis Colts | |
| Strong Safety Tennessee Titans | |
| Defensive End Chicago Bears | |
| Free Safety Denver Broncos | |
| Middle Linebacker Atlanta Falcons | |
| Second String Running Back New York Giants | |
| Backup QB Green Bay Packers | |
| Middle Linebacker Oakland Raiders | |
| Fullback Washington Redskins | |
| Tight End New York Jets | |
| Tight End Washington Redskins | |
| Kicker Seattle Seahawks | |
| Strong Safety Kansas City Chiefs | |
| Free Safety Green Bay Packers | |
| Punter Atlanta Falcons | |
| Starting QB Miami Dolphins | |
| Strong Safety Arizona Cardinals | |
| Third String Running Back Houston Texans | |