| Year - Position - School | Player | Pick |
| 2009 - RB - Ohio State | |
| 2008 - CB - Tennessee State | |
| 2007 - OT - Penn State | |
| 2006 - QB - USC | |
| 2005 - CB - Miami (Fl.) | |
| 2004 - WR - Pittsburgh | |
| 2003 - WR - Penn State | |
| 2003 - DE - Wake Forest | |
| 2002 - DT - Wisconsin | |
| 2001 - OT - Texas | |
| | Year - Position - School | Player | Pick |
| 2000 - RB - Virginia | |
| 1999 - WR - Ohio State | |
| 1999 - OT - Eastern Michigan | |
| 1998 - DE - Florida State | |
| 1997 - CB - Iowa | |
| 1996 - DE - Illinois | |
| 1994 - LB - UCLA | |
| 1993 - RB - Georgia | |
| 1993 - OT - South Carolina | |
| 1991 - DE - No College | |
|