| Percentage guessed (Party) | President |
| 54.3% (Republican) | |
| 55.6% (Republican) | |
| 57.1% (Republican) | |
| 57.2% (Democratic) | |
| 58.6% (Democratic) | |
| 58.7% (Whig) | |
| 63.6% (Democratic-Republican) | |
| 64.4% (Whig) | |
| 65.2% (Republican) | |
| 65.2% (Republican) | |
| 65.7% (Whig) | |
| 67.8% (Republican) | |
| 69.1% (Democratic) | |
| 70.7% (Democratic) | |
| 70.8% (Democratic) | |
| 71.1% (Republican) | |
| 71.7% (Whig) | |
| 74.7% (Republican) | |
| 75.2%(Republican) | |
| 75.2%(Democratic) | |
| 75.9% (Democratic) | |
| 77.2% (Democratic-Republican) | |
| | Percentage guessed (Party) | President |
| 77.3% (Republican) | |
| 79.3% (Democratic-Republican) | |
| 80.5% (Republican) | |
| 82.5% (Democratic-Republican) | |
| 83.3% (Republican) | |
| 86.4%(Democratic) | |
| 86.7% (Democratic National Union) | |
| 86.9% (Democratic) | |
| 90.4%(Republican) | |
| 91.2% (Republican) | |
| 91.5% (Democratic-Republican) | |
| 91.5% (Democratic) | |
| 91.5% (Republican) | |
| 92.6% (Federalist/Democratic-Republican) | |
| 92.7% (Democratic) | |
| 93.3% (Federalist) | |
| 94.5% (Republican) | |
| 95.1% (Democratic) | |
| 96.2% (Republican) | |
| 96.8% (Republican) | |
| 98.8% (None) | |
|