| Hint | Character |
| Let's call them Buffy Character, or BC. | |
| jj | |
| jjjj | |
| Nope, but BC is also a villain. | |
| BC is fairly useless, too! | |
| BC never appeared in Angel. | |
| BC did not appear in the first season. | |
| BC is not related to Buffy. | |
| BC is not a vampire. | |
| Who is Thomas? Not BC! | |
| Our little BC is definitely not friends with the Scoobies. | |
| BC is not a Cordette. | |
| BC is not a female. | |
| That would be too easy, wouldn't it? | |
| BC was never a series regular. | |
| No, but BC is somewhat proficient in magic! | |
| BC did not ever cross over into Angel. | |
| No, BC is not Ripper! | |
| BC never actually turned into a rat. | |
| BC is a magic-user as well. | |
| Why even guess this? | |
| BC is not a cheerleader. | |
| Nope. | |
| I don't know who this is, and you don't either. | |
| BC is a human. | |
| Are you even trying? | |
| Buffy never dated BC. | |
| Who? | |
| About equally as annoying as BC. | |
| Nope. | |
| Who? | |
| Nope. | |
| Who? | |
| Nope. | |
| Who? | |
| BC is not a robot. | |
| No, but BC is good at magic. | |
| Nope. | |
| BC was not a principal. | |
| BC is not related to Buffy. | |
| BC was never a vampire. | |
| BC was never a vampire. | |
| BC was a human. | |
| BC was not a Sunnydale High student. | |
| No, but BC is British. | |
| BC was sane. Probably. | |
| BC never sings. | |
| BC is not in a band. | |
| BC is significantly taller than Jonathan. | |
| BC is not a mummy. | |
| No, but BC does share a debut episode with Larry! | |
| Nope, BC is male. | |
| BC is not a Slayer. | |
| No, but BC is equally as useless, though. | |
| BC does not wear glasses. | |
| BC is a human. | |
| BC is definitely not a cop. | |
| BC is not a vampire. | |
| BC is not American. | |
| BC is not a demon. | |
| BC is not a bounty hunter of any sort. | |
| BC is not a demon. | |
| BC is not related to Buffy. | |
| BC is not a ghost. | |
| BC's death occurred in the Season 8 comics. | |
| BC is not a Watcher. | |
| There are no flashbacks containing BC. | |
| Joyce is not friends with BC. | |
| BC is not a vampire. | |
| Faith does not kill BC. | |
| BC is not a Slayer. | |
| Buffy never dated BC. | |
| BC doesn't die until the Season 8 comics. | |
| BC is never quite a 'Big Bad'. | |
| No, but BC is British. | |
| BC is much younger. | |
| BC is human. | |
| No, but BC is British. | |
| BC is relatively trim. | |
| Both are relatively awkward. | |
| BC never went to Sunnydale High. | |
| BC is not a Vengeance Demon. | |
| No, BC was captured by Riley, not hired by him! | |
| No, but they are a villain. | |
| Oh god no. | |
| BC is not a professor. | |
| Olivia is presumably a childhood friend of BC. | |
| Buffy never sleeps with BC. | |
| BC is not a werewolf. | |
| No, but Riley captures BC at one point. | |
| BC is presumably not a fan of the Initiative. | |
| BC is captured by the Initiative in Season 4. | |
| BC is a male, and probably straight. | |
| BC isn't much of a gentleman. | |
| BC is fully human. | |
| No, but the characters do seem similar. | |
| The Cheese Man is a red herring! | |
| BC lives in modern day. | |
| No, BC had a probably natural child birth. | |
| BC was not played by Tom Lenk! | |
| BC is not Glory! | |
| BC did not appear in Season 5. | |
| BC is a human male. | |
| BC is white. | |
| BC did not date Anya. | |
| BC is not part of the Council. | |
| BC has no relation to Glory. | |
| I don't believe BC ever purposely killed anyone. | |
| BC is a slave to no one! | |
| BC has no relation to Glory. | |
| BC is human. | |
| BC is not in the Trio. | |
| BC is not friends with Spike. | |
| BC is not friends with Dawn. | |
| BC does not appear in Season 6. | |
| Nope, not a shark. | |
| Also a magic user. | |
| BC is not friends with Riley. | |
| No, but BC's actor is named Robin. | |
| BC is not played by Camden Toy. | |
| BC is not aware of their impending death. | |
| BC never went to Sunnydale High. | |
| These things don't even have names! | |
| BC never dates Willow. | |
| BC is British, but not Cockney. | |
| BC is not a Potential. | |
| BC is not a Potential. | |
| BC is a brunette. | |
| BC is white. | |
| BC is not female. | |
| BC is not asian. | |
| BC is not a Bringer. | |
| BC never was a Slayer. | |
| BC is not a Potential. | |
| BC is not a Potential. | |