| Good Review | Best Picture Nominee | Bad Review |
| '[Title] is sugary, to be sure - but it is sugar cut with cannon fire and barbed wire and the horrors of war.' (Philadelphia Inquirer) | |
| 'It's a unique journey that's equal parts sympathy card and celebration of human resilience.' (RichardRoeper.com) | |
| 'Literally the kind of movie they just don't make anymore...' (New York Post) | |
| '[Title] brings a chick-flick sensibility to a serious subject, which is more daring than it might sound. It's also incredibly refreshing.' (Newsday) | |
| 'While its compatriots focus on strength, [Title] celebrates strategy, recounting the unlikely true story of how brains triumphed over brawn' (Cut Print Review) | |
| | Good Review | Best Picture Nominee | Bad Review |
| 'A haunting, piquant melodrama about childhood dreams and yearnings, enhanced with a pleasant survey course in early film history.' (Entertainment Weekly) | |
| '[Title] is at times trying and perplexing, but it also contains some of the most psychologically insightful and ecstatic filmmaking imaginable.' (San Fransico Chronicle) | |
| 'The last, touching final frame is worth the entrance price alone.' (Sky Movies) | |
| 'A sweet-natured trifle, as flavorful and as thin as a crepe.' (Boston Globe) | |
|