| Clue | C Thing | Musical |
| Galinda or Sally Brown | |
| A cowboy who lives in Oklahoma | |
| Life is a ______________ old chum | |
| Based on the story of King Arthur | |
| It's not about Dogs | |
| Either the Phantom's favorite singer, or his least favorite | |
| 1945 Rodgers and Hammerstein classic | |
| The title character of another Rodgers and Hammerstein collaboration, who has a fairy godmother | |
| The type of game Nathan Detroit organizes | |
| Get me to the _______ on time! | |
| | Clue | C Thing | Musical |
| He's a Superstar | |
| Set in the cold war, at a competition for a classic board game | |
| The opening number in A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | |
| Ado Annie, Guenevere, or Dorothy Brock | |
| The lieutenant who falls in love with a native of the South Pacific | |
| The daughter who Tevye cuts off after she elopes | |
| The city, or county, where Velma Kelly and Roxie Hart are held | |
| One of the sailors in New York for just a day, dates Hildy | |
| Composer of Annie and Bye Bye Birdie | |
| That doesn't start with C! The other one! | |
|