| Song | Contestant | Season |
| #30: 'Blackbird' | |
| #29: 'I (Who Have Nothing)' | |
| #28: 'I'll Stand By You' | |
| #27: 'Nature Boy' | |
| #26: 'Black Horse and the Cherry Tree' | |
| #25: 'Hallelujah' | |
| #24: 'My Funny Valentine' | |
| #23: 'A House is not a Home' | |
| #22: 'Over the Rainbow' | |
| #21: 'A Whole New World' | |
| #20: 'Hello' | |
| #19: 'Will You Love Me Tomorrow' | |
| #18: 'The House of the Rising Sun' | |
| #17: 'You Give Love a Bad Name' | |
| #16: 'Circle of Life' | |
| | Song | Contestant | Season |
| #15: 'Solitaire' | |
| #14: 'Me and Bobby McGee' | |
| #13: 'Natural Woman' | |
| #12: 'Cry Baby' | |
| #11: 'Hemorrhage (In My Hands)' | |
| #10: 'Imagine' | |
| #9: 'Alone' | |
| #8: 'Bridge Over Trouble Water' | |
| #7: 'Moody's Mood For Love' | |
| #6: 'Heartless' | |
| #5: 'Summertime' | |
| #4: 'In A Dream' | |
| #3: 'Stuff Like That There' | |
| #2: 'Mad World' | |
| #1: 'The World I Know' | |
|