| Rookie Season | Player | Other Awards |
| Tampa Bay Rays, 2008 | |
| Milwaukee Brewers, 2007 | |
| Boston Red Sox, 2007 | |
| Philadelphia Phillies, 2005 | |
| St. Louis Cardinals, 2001 | |
| Seattle Mariners, 2001 | |
| Kansas City Royals, 1999 | |
| Philadelphia Phillies, 1997 | |
| New York Yankees, 1996 | |
| Los Angeles Dodgers, 1994 | |
| Houston Astros, 1991 | |
| Minnesota Twins, 1991 | |
| San Diego Padres, 1987 | |
| Oakland Athletics, 1987 | |
| Oakland Athletics, 1986 | |
| New York Mets, 1984 | |
| Baltimore Orioles, 1982 | |
| Los Angeles Dodgers, 1981 | |
| Los Angeles Dodgers, 1979 | |
| Detroit Tigers, 1978 | |
| Montreal Expos, 1977 | |
| Baltimore Orioles, 1977 | |
| Boston Red Sox, 1975 | |
| Boston Red Sox, 1972 | |
| New York Yankees, 1970 | |
| Cincinnati Reds, 1968 | |
| New York Mets, 1967 | |
| Minnesota Twins, 1967 | |
| Cincinnati Reds, 1964 | |
| Chicago White Sox, 1966 | |
| Philadelphia Phillies, 1964 | |
| Cincinnati Reds, 1963 | |
| Chicago Cubs, 1961 | |
| San Francisco Giants, 1959 | |
| San Francisco Giants, 1958 | |
| Cincinnati Reds, 1956 | |
| Chicago White Sox, 1956 | |
| New York Giants, 1951 | |
| Brooklyn Dodgers, 1949 | |
| Brooklyn Dodgers, 1947 | |
|